Month: January 2014

ALLEGATIONS of aggressive and intimidating behaviour by people visiting Drumcliff have emerged amid calls for less restrictive access to the graveyard.

Fears that vehicles would damage graves led to the permanent locking last year of one half of the cemetery’s gates. There have also been reports that groups of people were observed drinking and behaving aggressively in Drumcliff on Christmas Day.

The issues were disclosed at the January meeting of Ennis Town Council as councillors discussed a motion tabled by Cllr Paul O’Shea (Ind).

Cllr O’Shea proposed the gates at Drumcliff be unlocked every second Sunday “to enable loved ones to transport tools, equipment, plants and flowers so as to maintain their loved one’s graves.”

Administrative officer Betty Devanny stated in her response that access to Drumcliff cemetery has been restricted since November 2013, with exception give to undertakers, grave diggers, memorial sculptors, caretaker and those with mobility difficulties.

She continued, “This is necessary to prevent possible damage occurring to the kerbing, grave surrounds, and grave markers from vehicles accessing the cemetery which hap- pened on a regular basis while the gates remained unlocked. It will also provide for better management of the cemetery.”

Ms Devanny said only one side of the double gates are locked so it is possible for people to bring tools and flowers to graves. She states extra staff would be required to facilitate Cllr O’Shea’s request. “In the current economic downturn and a staffing embargo in place, it is not possible to facilitate this request,” she added.

Cllr Michael Guilfoyle (Ind) told the meeting he had witnessed incidents where vehicles drove at speed around the graveyard. “When the gates were left open, it was abused,” he said.

Cllr Mary Howard (FG) said she saw people drive through the graveyard on Christmas Day and park up for 40-50 minutes. “There is no room to maneuver and damage will be done,” she warned.

Cllr Howard told the meeting she also witnessed the same group of people “drinking and being aggressive” on Christmas Day.

Mayor of Ennis, Cllr Mary Coote Ryan (FG) said she recently saw two carloads of people enter the graveyard in a “very intimidating fashion”.

“There are some people who do misbehave and cause trouble for others,” she added.

Town manager Gerard Dollard said the changes at Drumcliff were introduced for the better management of the facility.

LAST year was a record year for trgan transplants in Ireland, with at least six transplant recipients from Clare. One third of the Clare transplants were from living donors.

Four Clare people received kidney transplants last year while another was the recipient of a kidney and pancreas transplant.

There was at least one lung transplant recipient in the county.

Among the success stories were two living kidney transplant recipients in Clare both of whom received their transplants from family members.

Both transplants were carried out at Beaumount Hospital Dublin and both the donors and recipients have recovered well.

“The gift they have received has given these people a second chance at life as they now have a life free of dialysis. It’s the gift the recipients are so grateful for, as prior to been transplanted they were depending on machines to survive,” said Peggy Eustace of the Clare branch of the Irish Kidney Association.

“Sadly there have also been many donor families in Clare. We thank them for the generosity they have shown in donating their loved ones organs at a very difficult time for themselves.”

In 2013 as many as 293 organs were transplanted in Ireland compared to the previous record of 275 in 2011.

The highlight achievement was the growth in lung transplantation in the Mater Hospital from a record 14 in 2012 to a staggering 32 in 2013.

This is more than the equivalent of the previous four years of lung transplantation from 2009 to 2012, which totalled 31.

The second highlight is the consistently record-breaking living donor kidney transplant programme in Beaumont Hospital, which had 38 living donors and resulting transplants.

It brings the total living donor kidney transplants to 155 since the start of the service seven years ago.

The generosity of the 86 deceased donors and their families in 2013 dramatically altered and saved the lives of 245 people, 10 of whom received two organs.

There were 55 liver transplants performed in St Vincent’s Hospital and 11 heart transplants also conducted in the Mater Hospital.

In Beaumont Hospital a total of 195 transplant operations took place. 185 kidney operations, of which 38 were from living donors and 147 from deceased donors, 10 of the 147 also had simultaneous pancreas transplants.

THERE have been calls to remove beggars from the streets of Ennis after concern was raised that women are being “trafficked” into the town to beg.

Cllr Paul O’Shea (Ind) has requested the council “work with appropriate authorities such as social welfare inspectors to ascertain if those who continue to beg on the streets of Ennis are in receipt of social welfare payments”.

He called on the council to endeavour to make Ennis a begging free zone n 2014 so as to encourage tourism in the town.

At the council’s January meeting, town clerk Leonard Cleary said the issue of begging was recently discussed at the Ennis Joint Policing Committee on December 16.

He stated, “Ennis Town Council will work with the Gardaí and other agencies in relation to this matter. In addition the JPC discussed the importance of balancing support for local charities with national charity collections visiting Ennis. Again, the council will liaise with the relevant agencies.”

Cllr O’Shea told the meeting he had seen the same people begging on the streets of Clonmel and Ennis.

Cllr Johnny Flynn (FG) said women are “rotated” in and out of the Ennis area. He said some of the women are often forced into “other activities”. Cllr Flynn told the meeting there were reports locally that the women are dropped into Ennis by a man driving a Mercedes car.

“There is abuse of women and children in this,” he added. Cllr Mary Howard (FG) said gardaí believe women are being “trafficked” into Ireland for the purposes of begging. She also criticised the activities of some charity collectors or “chuggers”.

Cllr Howard said some of those collecting money around Dunnes Stores and the Post Office can be “intimidating and abusive”.

YEARS spent studying the ocean off the North Clare coast paid off for Lisdoonvarna student Stephen O’Connell last week after he took first place in the Biological and Ecological Category of the BT Young Scientist Exhibition.

Stephen was one of six students from Mary Immaculate Secondary School to receive an award at this year’s Young Scientist. Indeed, nine of the 10 Clare projects at this year’s event came from Lisdoonvarna, with one project from Scoil Mhuire in Ennistymon also making the final.

Stephen, whose father fishes off the coast of Doolin and Liscannor, has entered the competition on two previous occasions, with each project exploring different aspects of fishing in the area.

Stephen profiled more than 1,200 crabs caught off the Clare coast and developed a method for separating low quality and high quality crab meat. His work could have a major impact on the quality of crab being produced by the Irish crab industry.

The school also had great performances from Rhianna McMahon and her brother Keelan who took second place in their category as well as winning the EMC Data Hero Award.

Second year students Tess Casasin Sheridan and Aoife Doherty received the Geological Survey of Ireland Award for their project while David Sims was Highly Commended for his project.

“This is Stephen’s third year in the exhibition and they all have been building in the same area. His father and his uncle are both fishermen so that is what Stephen knows best. It is a great advantage to have a project that the student has an interest in and has a lot of knowledge around,” said John Sims of Mary Immaculate Secondary School.

“Keelan and Rhianna did very well as well, coming second in their category and also winning the EMC Data Hero Award. This award is for data analysis and they had 20,000 lines of data in their project which was a great achievement.

“The standard was so high this year and I think everyone did really really well. It was above my wildest dreams that everyone did so well. It was a great achievement.”

ENNIS’ effor ts to become Ireland’s tidiest town have been boosted by a € 4,000 increase in funding from Ennis Town Council.

At the council’s annual budget meeting last week, members unanimously voted in favour of a motion to allocate extra funds to the Ennis Tidy Town’s Committee.

Cllr Tommy Brennan (Ind) proposed cutting by half money allo- cated for the mayor’s allowance in 2014.

The Ennis councillor told the meeting the money could instead be given to Tidy Towns as Ennis would only have a mayor for another six months.

It is expected that the town council will be replaced by a municipal authority after this year’s local elections.

Cll r Brennan’s proposal came in response to a suggestion put forward by Cll r Brian Meaney (GP).

A Fianna Fáí l candidate in the 2014 local elections, Cll r Meaney called on the council to increase the increase the cost of using the town’s automated public toilets from 25 cents to 50 cents.

The meeting heard the proposal would generate additional income of € 2, 000.

The council estimates it will cost € 70, 000 to maintain and service the two ‘superloos’ in 2014.

Cllr Meaney’s proposal was supported by Cllr Johnny Flynn (FG) who said some of the extra income should go towards tackling the “graffiti epidemic” in the town.

However it was strongly opposed by other councillors. Cllr Brennan said, “For anyone even to suggest it is disgraceful.”

The council will give a contribution of € 16, 000 to Ennis Tidy Towns. Cllr Brennan said an extra € 4,000 could be found by cutting the mayor’s annual allowance. Cll r Brennan’s motion was unanimously voted through by all nine members. Cllr Meaney’s motion was defeated by five votes to four.

Town manager Gerard Dollard told the meeting the council would also look favourably on any application from the Ennis Defibrillator Committee for community grant funding. This was after a request from Cllr Paul O’Shea (Ind).

Going down on his knees as Tuesday’s meeting neared conclusion, Cllr O’Shea urged the council to provide financial support to the committee.

ENNIS Town Council is facing legal bills of over € 500,000 arising from two separate High Court cases.

The local authority says it is “seriously concerned” regarding the number of High Court cases, which are falling to the council.

Following a number of High Court hearings, the council last year secured a settlement in relation to a case taken on the Ennis Casual Trading Byelaws 2011, which represented a challenge to the Casual Trading Act 1995. The case concerned the status of casual trading vis-a-vis market rights. According to the council’s 2014 budget report, the overall cost in this case amounted to € 147,000.

The council is also currently involved in a High Court case regarding the de-regulation of the taxi industry.

In his report, town manager Gerard Dollard states, “The case has been in process for a number of years and commenced in November 2013. The case has been taken against the State (Minister and Attorney General). A number of sample cases are being heard including three involving Dublin City Council and one involving Ennis Town Council.

Mr Dollard said the council has made efforts to run the case on a cost effective basis. However the case is still at hearing and Mr Dollard told the council’s annual budget meeting that the costs at this point are in excess of € 400,000. The council recently received an interim bill from Counsel for € 191,000.

Mr Dollard states, “The council has firmly put the view to both the Department of the Environment, Community and Local Government and Department of Transport, Tourism and Sport that the costs of cases involving challenges to national legislation and regulation should not fall on the local authority.”

Mr Dollard told Tuesday’s meeting the council will receive € 250,000 from the Department of the Environment towards the cost of the court cases.

Cllr Peter Considine (FF) described the bills as “crippling” and asked if the council can challenge the Department’s decision not to cover the cost of the entire legal process.

Cllr Tommy Brennan (Ind) said the decision by the Minister for the Environment to part fund the legal bills represented an admission on his part that his office was responsible for the total cost. “I would go back to the Minister and say pay for all of it,” he said.

A CLARE man who owes almost € 1.8 million is the largest debtor to come before the Personal Insolvency Court so far, the Insolvency Service of Ireland (ISI) has confirmed.

The first sitting at Ennis District Court of the Personal Insolvency Court for the South Western Circuit took place on Thursday.

The case before Judge Patrick Meaghan concerned a Clare man with total qualifying liabilities of € 1.77 million. The man was seeking a protection certificate from the court to allow time to enter into negotiations with his creditors.

Figures shown to the court revealed the man had total assets of € 394,900, a monthly income of € 5,687 and monthly expenses of € 5,994.

The man is a married father of one. The court heard he is an engineer currently working in Finland. His debts concern money owed to financial institutions for commercial premises in Limerick and Dublin along with two buy-to-let properties. In total, the man has 14 creditors.

The man was not present in court but was represented by Personal Insolvency Practitioner (PIP) John Hogan. The ISI were also represented in court.

Judge Patrick Meaghan said the debtor was obviously insolvent. He said he was satisfied to grant the protection certificate. He wished the man all the best. The man now has 70 days to strike a deal with creditors. Judge Patrick Meaghan said he was pleased to see members of the press attending the court sitting. He said the Personal Insolvency Court is a new jurisdiction in which there is a lot of public interest. He said that press coverage had so far been “very fair and balanced”.

He said behind every case are people with difficulties. He asked the media to refrain from identifying the debtor and his creditors. Judge Meaghan added, “It is a matter that is very topical, but hopefully with sensitivity things can be progressed.”

According to it’s website, “The mission of the ISI is to help restore people who are insolvent to solvency in a fair, transparent and equitable way.”

The ISI is an independent statutory body. It was established by the Minister for Justice and Equality, Alan Shatter, TD on March 1, 2013.

Speaking after the hearing, PIP John Hogan said he thought the ISI was “doing a fantastic job”.

“The only problem with the legislation is that it should have happened four years ago. It might have saved a few marriages,” he added.

Mr Hogan said half of the people who have engaged his services as a PIP (8 or 9) come from Clare.

Mr Hogan, an Ennis-based accountant, is one of two PIPs registered in Clare. The other is another Ennis based accountant, John Carmody.

CALLS have been made for a sustained “period of civil disobedience” to take place in Clare following the closure of the acute assessment unit at Ennis General Hospital last week.

The subject was discussed following an emergency adjournment of yesterday’s January meeting of Clare County Council with councillors voting to write to the Minister for Health, James Reilly (FG), to demand that new staff are deployed to the Ennis hospital.

The acute assessment unit was closed for a number of days last week with Clare patients being referred to Limerick, which was also suffering acute overcrowding at the time. The Clare People understands that the closure in Ennis was a result of a single doctor being off on sick leave and a replacement doctor not being made available. A replacement doctor was eventually deployed from but the Ennis unit was forced to close for a number of days.

Independent Cllr James Breen, called for the public to take direct action against the Government in an effort to force the HSE to deploy more staff to Ennis General Hospital.

“It is just not good enough. We have been given promises from minister after minister all saying that we would have a first class medical service here in Clare. We can throw money at everything; we have € 50 million to spent on consultants for Irish Water but people cannot get life or death tests carried out at Ennis General Hospital,” he said.

“I think the time has come for a long period of civil disobedient in this country. People should stop paying their property tax. People in unions should stop paying those unions, because the unions are not doing what they are supposed to.”

The motion was seconded by Cllr Johnny Flynn (FG).

“The population of this county is receiving a second class service when this medical assessment unit in not open,” said Cllr Flynn.

THE section of the M18 which was closed on two separate occasion following a series of traffic accident on December 19 last, was gritted on three separate occasion immediately before being closed.

Clare County Council is to write to the National Roads Authority (NRA) requesting that a risk assessment be carried out a section of the M18 closed to Crusheen, which councillors yesterday claimed was defective.

“A number of people contacted me over the last few months in relation to this section of road. The NRA reply is filled with a lot of jargon about the road,” said Cllr Pat Hayes (FF).

“There was an unfortunate fatality in this area and there seems to be a continous problem with flooding on this section of the road. The people in Crusheen have a real concern about this section of the roadway and this has to be resolved. The NRA have given a very specific answer as to why this section of roadway was closed on the 19th (December) but this is an ongoing issue.

“We need to find out why there have been so many accidents on this section of roads. I am not putting blame on anyone but we need to talk to the NRA get to the bottom of this issue.”

The motion was supported by Cllr Patricia McCarthy (Ind).

“There is something wrong with that road. You have cars aquaplaning when you don’t expect it to happen. I’m not an engineer, but I know as a driver when I don’t feel secure on this part of the road. It is time that they go out and investigate this and get to the bottom it.”

Senior engineer with Clare County Council, Tom Tiernan said that the NRA have carried out investigation on this section of the M18 in the past.

“In relation to the fatality and a number of other accidents I do know that the NRA have come on the ground afterwards and examined what could have been the cause of these accidents,” he said.

THE prospect of swarming bees chasing stampeding cattle over dangerous cliffs in the Burren was raised at Clare County Council yesterday, as councillors could not decide whether to support a project to creation an Apiary (or bee sanctuary) in the Burren.

A motion to support plans by NUI, Galway, and other agencies to help reintroduce bees to the Burren created an unexpected stir at last night January meeting of Clare County Council, with a heated argument breaking out between North Clare based Cllr Michael Kelly (FF) and Ennis Cllr Johnny Flynn (FG).

The motion was opposed by Cllr Kelly who claimed that the introduction of bees would lead to cattle stampeded, which would result in the injury and death of animals.

“I am opposed this motion. Farmers are well aware that swarms of bees can cause a stampedes of cattle. I wish the bee keepers every success but if Cllr Flynn can suggest a site for this in Ennis, I would be very happy to supported it,” he said.

“I have 50 years of experience in farming in the Burren and if this goes ahead I have no doubt that it will create swarms of bees which will interfere with farmers and cattle.

“If the Burren floura is to flourish, it needs to be grazed during the summer. If you put bees into the Burren you won’t be able to graze cattle there safely.

“If you get an expert (from NUI, Galway) to speak here, of course they will be in favour of it, because they don’t have land in the Burren and they won’t have cattle with broken legs following stampeded in the Burren.”

Following a long debate on the motion, it was decided to defer a vote until expert opinion on the subject are invited to speak before Clare County Council.

“The experts at NUI, Galway and GMIT have a number of sites already in the Burren. With the history of organisations such as BurrenBeo and the significate investment already given to further farming practice in the Burren [the Burren Farming for Conservation Project] and there is an agreement that the Burren is the perfect spot for something like this. I would not consider that there would be any significant danger to livestock through this. Bee keeping is not an illegl activity; you can do it anywhere. This is not something new.”