This article is from page 75 of the 2011-07-12 edition of The Clare People. OCR mistakes are to be expected so download the original SWF or the rendered page 75 JPG
DESPITE NOT winning a championship game under his watch, history will in time reflect very favourably on Ger O’Loughlin’s two year reign as Clare senior hurling manager. The Sparrow resigned on Wednesday following his side’s comprehensive championship exit at the hands of neighbours Galway, their fourth straight championship defeat, with inexperience highlighted as the main source of defeat.
From the outset of his managerial appointment in December 2009, O’Loughlin’s commitment to blooding youth and building for the future was admirable. However, while he may have originally planned to gradually introduce the All-Ireland Under 21 winning panel to top flight hurling, his hand was forced somewhat by the retirements of Niall Gillian, Tony Carmody and Tony Griffin and subsequently Gerry O’Grady to injury later in the year. Those four players along with Jonathan Clancy, Diarmuid McMahon, Brian O’Connell, Pat Vaughan, Brendan Bugler, Patrick Donnellan and Alan Markham would have provided an experienced core for O’Loughlin to build his new side upon, with a sprinkling of younger talent complimenting that experience.
It was not to be however and instead, the Sparrow was forced to concentrate on building a completely new look side around the Under 21’s that would be capable of competing for top honours in a projected timeline of 3-4 years. In his first championship game in charge against Waterford, O’Loughlin entered unprecedented territory by handing debuts to nine players and it almost paid dividends while three more were given their first championship outings in 2011.
However, while the Sparrow’s foresight and courage was to be commended, the short term results didn’t reflect kindly on Clare who failed to achieve their primary goal of emerging from Division 2 of the National League. Had they managed to beat Wexford or Limerick in either final, O’Loughlin might have been heartened sufficiently to maintain his long term rebuilding plan but having to face a third year in the basement of Division 2 was too much.
Small margins derailed Clare’s cause to an extent as had they won either league final, it may have been the big breakthrough this young squad so badly needed in terms of confidence and development. In turn, they would have also boosted Clare’s championship campaigns that in both years saw very encouraging signs for the future in their Munster openers against perennial superpowers Waterford and Tipperary, only to sour the subsequent summers with sub- standard displays against Dublin and Galway in the All-Ireland series.
There is no denying that inexperience was the main issue but O’Loughlin simply had no option but to stick to his convictions and put all his faith in his young charges. In 2010, Clare lost to Waterford by 0-22 to 1-15, using 19 players with a combined total of 165 championship games behind them, averaging nine games experience for each player (including a late cameo for Alan Markham who alone made up over a quarter of those appearances at 45 games). All the more admirable when you consider that nine of those 19 were playing in their first senior championship game while also fac- ing a Waterford side with 520 games experience, an average of 26 games each. A game later, a young Dublin side had almost twice Clare’s experience at 270 games or 14 games for each player.
This year, with no Markham or Brian O’Connell (emigrated), O’Loughlin handed out two more debuts to Cratloe duo Conor McGrath and Cathal McInerney and took on All-Ireland champions Tipperary head on, with only 124 championship games under their belts as compared to the Premier’s 374, with Brendan Cummins and Eoin Kelly having almost as much championship experience as the entire 18 man Clare side that day. Finally Galway went back to their roots and had a combined total of 312 championship games experience that proved too much for Clare.
There is still some naivety and greenness to be knocked off them while the squad seemingly learned very little defensively from their Division 2 campaign. When a team is conceding 2-17 to Westmeath, 1-18 to Kerry and 3-16 to Laois, it is almost impossible to expect them to hold out All-Ireland champions Tipperary who devastatingly put seven goals past Waterford in Sunday’s Munster final, or against Galway who also showed their firepower against Cork on Saturday.
There was a hint of Ger O’Loughlin’s impending resignation immediately after the 17 point defeat to Galway just over a week ago when he reflected on his time as manager but also reckoning that the squad weren’t that far away from making the breakthrough.
“When I went in, after a couple of weeks, I knew that we were starting off from a very low base with regard to experienced players and we have had to start from scratch but I think we have made progress even though the results are poor.
“I think we actually have a nucleus built up to go forward but we need that injection again of five or six, 18, 19 and 20 year olds over the next year or two. But Clare will win something I think in the next three years. It might take three years but I think they’ll win something.”
They may yet prove to be very prophetic words indeed in light of Clare’s second successive Munster minor title victory on Sunday. The ingredients are there, the future is indeed bright and it will be noted that The Sparrow sowed the seeds by blooding the 2009 Under 21 panel. It’s now up to the new manager to nurture those crops further in the hope of reaping a blossoming future harvest.